More

    When a Black Friday “Was” Price Is Misleading: The Two Tests Regulators Use

    Every November, retailers publish a number with a line through it next to a smaller number. The smaller number is the one you pay. The struck-through number is the claim, and in both the United States and Canada it is governed by rules that ask a specific question: was anybody actually paying that higher price?

    The US rule: a former price has to be a real price

    The Federal Trade Commission’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, at 16 CFR 233.1, deal directly with former price comparisons. If the old price is "the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time," the comparison is legitimate. If the higher price was invented to make a later cut look generous, the guide calls the bargain false and notes that the "reduced" price is probably just the seller’s regular price.

    The regulation includes a worked example worth remembering. A retailer whose normal price is $7.50 briefly lists an item at $10, sells almost nothing at that price, then advertises "Were $10, Now Only $7.50." That is a false claim even though the $10 figure technically existed on a shelf for a few days.

    The same section also warns against implying a former price was a selling price, rather than an asking price, unless substantial sales happened at that number. "Formerly sold at" is a stronger claim than "formerly listed at."

    The Canadian rule: a volume test and a time test

    Canada’s Competition Act treats ordinary price claims as a civil matter under subsections 74.01(2) and 74.01(3), and the Competition Bureau publishes the tests it applies. A reference price is valid if it meets either:

    • Volume test: more than 50% of sales of the product happened at that price or higher within a reasonable period, usually the year before or after the promotion.
    • Time test: the product was offered for sale in good faith at that price or higher for a substantial period, which the Bureau measures as more than 50% of the relevant time, usually the six months before or after.

    "In good faith" is doing real work there. The Bureau looks at whether the product was openly available in appropriate volumes, whether the price reflected sound pricing principles, and whether the seller expected the market to validate it. The Bureau has also issued a Black Friday warning telling businesses that a made-up regular price violates the Act, which suggests the pattern is common enough to warrant a seasonal reminder.

    The three checks that catch most fake discounts

    1. Look at the price history, not the badge. Price-tracking tools and browser extensions record what a listing actually sold for over months. A "40% off" tag in front of a price that has not moved since August is a marketing event, not a discount.
    2. Check whether the reference is the retailer’s own price or someone else’s. "Compare at" or "list price" usually refers to a manufacturer’s suggested price, which the Bureau specifically says should not be presented as a regular price, because retailers routinely sell below it.
    3. Judge the deal by the number you pay. If $79 is a good price for that pair of headphones in November, it is a good price whether the tag says it was $129 or $99. The crossed-out figure is the retailer’s argument, not your evidence.

    What to do when the math looks wrong

    In the US, complaints go to the FTC and, for many product categories, your state attorney general. In Canada, the Competition Bureau takes information from consumers through its complaint channel. Neither will resolve an individual purchase, so keep the ad, the date and a screenshot of the product page; price claims are judged on what was advertised at the time.

    It also pays to know the store’s own rules before you buy. Return windows, restocking fees and price-adjustment policies decide whether a price that drops next week is your problem or theirs. Our guide to checking the real total before you buy online covers the fees and add-ons that change the effective price.

    What we did not do

    This article is about the rules, not about any specific retailer’s current sale. It does not name a product price because prices change hourly during Black Friday, and a number captured this afternoon can be wrong by tonight. The regulatory text and the Bureau’s guidance are the sources; anything a store tells you about its own discount should be measured against them.

    Stocked supermarket shelves
    Supermarket shelves. Photo: Maksym Kozlenko, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

    Sources

    Latest articles

    spot_imgspot_img

    Related articles

    Leave a reply

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    spot_imgspot_img